Mystery Bay is the far south coast the locals keep for themselves — granite boulders, clear coves, a bush campground and not a single shop. Oakleigh Farm Cottages sits on farmland just up the road, putting that coastline and the National Trust villages of Tilba within minutes of your veranda.
★ 4.8 · 62 Google reviews (correct at the time of writing, July 2026)
Property photo via Google Maps
The setting
The property works the classic south-coast combination: paddocks meeting bush, with the sea glittering beyond. Guests consistently rate it among the region’s best stays — 4.8 stars across dozens of reviews.
Around the cottages
Swim the coves at Mystery Bay, take the 1080 lookout at Narooma for seals and stingrays around the bar, do the Gulaga walk from Tilba Tilba, and finish with cheese tasting in Central Tilba’s heritage main street. Montague Island tours — seals, penguins, and whales in season — run out of Narooma, 10 minutes away.
Header image shows the surrounding Mystery Bay region — see the property’s website for accommodation photos. Rates, availability and inclusions are set by the property.
🏅 Own or manage this place? Get your “Featured on AustralianSecret” badge
Show visitors you're featured in our independent directory — copy this snippet into your website. The badge links back to your listing here.
